The Added Value of Multiple Credit Reports: Expand Coverage and Reduce Misses
Excellent financial risk management requires maximum coverage, high accuracy and precise timing. While other credit reporting companies excel with broad coverage of private companies, CreditRiskMonitor shines brightest in the public company landscape. With corporate debt now exceeding a record $6.2 trillion – and growing – astute risk managers are prudently monitoring their exposure to public companies.
Risk professionals are often surprised that about 53% of all trade dollars are tied to public companies. Public companies tend to be larger than private ones, which is part of the reason for this astonishing figure. Further, many public companies also own private companies, resulting in a parent-subsidiary relationship. When a parent public company files for bankruptcy, the private subsidiaries can file for bankruptcy too. Take for instance, the Elder-Beerman Stores Corp., a subsidiary of The Bon-Ton Stores, Inc. When Bon-Ton filed for bankruptcy in February 2018, so did its subsidiaries, including the Elder-Beerman Stores.
CreditRiskMonitor provides commercial credit reporting on more than 58,000 public companies globally. The FRISK® score is updated daily and measures financial stress and bankruptcy risk with 96%* accuracy. CreditRiskMonitor also continues to expand its coverage on private companies, spanning more than 80,000 businesses. Subscribers use our service and another platform to monitor all of their suppliers, customers and partners.
Why Other Methods Fail
Some credit reporting agencies look at aggregate payment behavior, judgements and liens to measure company financial risk. While these factors provide insight on risk for some private companies, our research shows that this approach is foolhardy when assessing public companies.
Pertaining to payment behavior, the issue is twofold. Many strong corporations, such as Walmart and Apple, tend to pay their vendors slowly to maximize cash efficiency. Conversely, highly distressed operators might be more inclined to pay their suppliers on time to mask financial stress. In short, relying on a trade payment model for a public company, including the Days Beyond Terms (DBT) Index, can result in a complete miss.
Using financial statements is a better approach, but it isn’t without challenges. The Altman Z”-Score, for example, is widely-used for predicting public company financial stress, but it has some drawbacks. There have been many misleading cases with large public companies where the Z”-Score was:
- Too optimistic; a strong Z”-Score at the time of bankruptcy (e.g., SolarWorld AG)
- Too pessimistic; a weak Z”-Score but a low chance of bankruptcy (e.g., Hewlett Packard Enterprise)
- Too early; a Z”-Score was weak for many years prior to bankruptcy (e.g., Sears Holdings Corporation)
- Too late; a Z”-Score was strong except for the last quarter prior to filing (e.g., The Bon-Ton Stores, Inc.)
Furthermore, financial statements are only updated periodically. In the U.S., corporations report their financials quarterly, but for international companies, the reporting period can expand to semi-annually or annually. A lot can happen intra-quarter, let alone in the span of an entire year. Putting it all together, using financial models alone for public companies, such as the Z-score, can result in a complete miss or poor timing.
Best Practices with the FRISK® score
Key inputs of the FRISK® score are four high-quality data components including adjusted market data, unique financial statement ratios, agency credit ratings and proprietary subscriber crowdsourcing. Each of these factors have been incorporated using disparate sensitivities and non-linear weightings. These four factors mitigate each other’s shortcomings and ultimately provide a more accurate result than any one factor alone. Together, the FRISK® score can identify financial stress with 96% accuracy in a coming 12-month period.
The FRISK® score uses a “10” (financially strongest) to “1” (financially weakest) scale. Companies that have a FRISK® score of “6” or higher are generally acceptable to start or maintain business with. Companies that have a FRISK® score of “5” or lower, also known as the FRISK® score “red zone,” should be carefully monitored. See the FRISK® scale below:
Any company in the red zone is considered to be financially stressed, and therefore has an elevated probability of default and/or bankruptcy. We recommend that any business that stands between a FRISK® score of “1” and “3” be intensely reviewed and steps should be taken to reduce exposure. If you miss a public company bankruptcy, the consequences can be catastrophic.
Given corporate debt stands at record highs, more and more risk professionals are wary of their exposure to public companies. With the FRISK® score, subscribers quickly identify which of their public company counterparties are at increased risk of financial distress and bankruptcy. If a given business is in the FRISK® red zone, it is an important warning signal and should be monitored carefully. Public company bankruptcies lead to massive financial loss and disrupted supply chains; don’t let it happen to your business.
*As backtested on U.S. public companies; results may vary for private companies and by country. All references to the FRISK® score’s accuracy on the CreditRiskMonitor website are qualified by this statement.
CreditRiskMonitor is a financial news and analysis service designed to help professionals stay ahead of public company risk quickly, accurately and cost-effectively. More than 35% of the Fortune 1000, plus thousands more worldwide, rely on our commercial credit reporting and predictive risk analytics for assessing the financial stability of over 58,000 global public companies.
At the core of CreditRiskMonitor’s service is its 96% accurate FRISK® score, which is formulated to predict public company bankruptcy risk. One of four key components calculated in the FRISK® score is crowdsourced subscriber activity. This unique system tracks subscribers' patterns of research activity, capturing and aggregating the real-time concerns of what are essentially the key gatekeepers of corporate credit. Other features of CreditRiskMonitor’s service include timely news alerts, the Altman Z” score, agency ratings, financial ratios and trends. CreditRiskMonitor’s network of trade contributors provides more than $135 billion in trade data on their counterparties every month, giving them visibility into their biggest dollar risks.